ESupplyHQ
Tools

Impact Driver vs. Drill: Which One Do You Actually Need

Tool Reviews · 5 min read

Independent and reader-supported. ESupplyHQ is a small, family-run business built on 30 years in the maintenance trade. If you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission from the retailer, at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend, and it helps keep these guides free. Our disclosure.

These two tools look similar enough that a lot of first-time buyers assume they're interchangeable, then wonder why their impact driver chews up a drill bit or their drill can't sink a 3-inch deck screw without stalling. They're built for different jobs.

What a drill is actually good at

A drill's strength is control. The clutch settings let you dial in exactly how much torque gets applied, which matters for drilling clean holes and driving smaller screws without stripping the head or driving it too deep. It's the right tool for anything involving drill bits, hole saws, or paddle mixing attachments.

What an impact driver is actually good at

An impact driver delivers rotational force in rapid bursts rather than one steady twist, which is what lets it drive long screws, lag bolts, and deck screws without stalling or requiring you to lean your body weight into it. That same burst delivery is also what's hard on standard drill bits — it can crack them under repeated impact, which is why impact drivers are built around impact-rated driver bits instead.

The simple rule

If the job involves drilling a hole, use a drill. If the job involves driving a long or large-diameter fastener, use an impact driver. Deck building, fence building, and furniture assembly with long screws lean impact driver. Cabinet installation, small trim work, and anything needing a hole drilled first lean drill.

Do you need both, or just one?

For light, occasional use — hanging pictures, small furniture assembly, the occasional shelf — a drill alone covers most of it. Once a project involves any kind of deck, fence, subfloor, or framing work, an impact driver stops being optional; trying to do that work with a drill alone means stripped screw heads and a lot of frustration.

Buying them as a combo kit is almost always cheaper than buying each separately later, and it means both tools share the same battery platform from day one.

One thing worth knowing before you buy

Impact driver bits and standard drill bits are not interchangeable in either direction long-term. Standard bits can shatter under an impact driver's force, and impact-rated bits are unnecessarily expensive for light drill use. Keep a separate small set of impact-rated bits once you own an impact driver.

Drills and impact drivers to consider on Amazon

Listed from lowest to highest price when we last checked; check Amazon for the current price.

Drill

BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX Brushless 1/2" Drill (BLD782D1)

A brushless drill/driver with a 1/2-inch chuck for drilling holes and everyday driving, with a 2Ah battery and charger.

Impact driver

CRAFTSMAN V20 Brushless Compact Impact Driver Kit (CMCF811D1)

A compact brushless impact driver for long screws and lag bolts, sold as a kit with battery and charger.

Both, plus a saw

CRAFTSMAN V20 MAX 4-Tool Combo Kit (CMCK401D2AM)

Our top pick if you need both: a drill/driver, impact driver, 6-1/2-inch circular saw and work light on one battery platform. See all our combo kits.

Keep track of what you own: Workshop Safety Audit + Tool Inventory — Printable workshop and garage safety audit checklist (55+ checks) plus an Excel tool inventory with serial numbers, warranties and battery totals. $5.